Change orders are a frequent yet formidable challenge in the construction industry. They can stem from evolving client needs, unexpected site conditions, or design adjustments, each posing potential disruptions to the project flow.
Handling change orders efficiently is crucial for project managers, but it also comes with its own set of challenges.
From ensuring accurate documentation and managing cost implications to maintaining project schedules and coordinating with multiple stakeholders, the pressure is on to keep everything on track.
In this blog, we’ll explore the key problems project managers face with change order management and offer actionable insights to tackle these obstacles, ensuring smoother project execution and enhance overall success.
First, let's understand change orders in proper detail!
What is a Change Order in Construction?
A change order in construction is a formal document used to modify the original terms of a construction contract. It typically arises when there are changes to the scope of work, materials, design, or other aspects of the project that were not anticipated when the contract was initially signed. Change orders can also include changes in the project schedule, budget, or both.
Change orders are a common occurrence in construction projects, as they allow for flexibility and adaptability when unexpected issues arise or when project requirements evolve. However, they can also lead to delays and cost overruns if not managed properly.
Common Reasons for Change Orders
Change orders in construction are often necessary due to various unforeseen circumstances or evolving project needs. Here are some common reasons for change orders:
- Design Changes: Modifications requested by the client after the design phase can lead to changes in the project scope, requiring adjustments to the construction plan, materials, or methods.
- Unforeseen Site Conditions: Unexpected issues like poor soil conditions, hidden utilities, or archaeological finds can necessitate changes to the original plans.
- Errors or Omissions in Design: Mistakes or missing details in the initial design documents can require corrections, leading to change orders.
- Regulatory Changes: New or updated building codes, safety regulations, or environmental laws can force changes in the construction approach, materials, or schedule.
- Material Availability or Substitution: If specified materials are unavailable or delayed, substitutions may be required, affecting costs and timelines.
- Client Requests: The client might request changes to the scope, such as additional features, upgrades, or aesthetic alterations, after the project has begun.
- Scope Creep: Gradual, incremental changes to the project’s scope, often driven by the client, can lead to multiple change orders if not managed carefully.
- Budget Adjustments: If the project’s budget is revised due to funding issues or cost-saving measures, changes to the scope or materials may be required.
- Weather Conditions: Extreme weather events can damage the site or materials, leading to necessary changes in the construction plan or schedule.
- Subcontractor Issues: Delays or problems with subcontractors, such as labor shortages or performance issues, might necessitate changes in the schedule or approach.
- Value Engineering: Efforts to optimize the project’s cost-effectiveness or performance can lead to changes in materials, design, or construction methods.
Change orders are an essential tool for managing these kinds of challenges, but they need to be handled carefully to minimize disruption and maintain project control.
Ready to learn more about the different kinds of change orders you'll come across? Let's break them down.
6 Types of Change Orders in Construction
Change orders in construction can vary based on their nature and the reasons behind them. Here are some common types of change orders:
- Additive Change Order
This type involves adding new work or expanding the project scope. It typically increases both the project’s cost and duration. For example, a client might request additional features or enhancements not included in the original contract.
- Deductive Change Order
In contrast to an additive change order, a deductive change order reduces the scope of work. This could happen if the client decides to remove certain features or scale back the project. It usually results in a cost reduction and may also shorten the project timeline.
- No-Cost Change Order
A change that does not affect the project’s overall cost but alters the scope, materials, or schedule. This type of change order could occur when the project scope changes, but the contractor can adjust other aspects to offset any cost impact.
- Substitution Change Order
Involves substituting materials, methods, or equipment specified in the original contract with alternatives. This could be due to material unavailability, cost considerations, or client preference. The cost and time impact can vary depending on the substitution.
- Constructive Change Order
This occurs when a contractor performs work that they believe is beyond the scope of the original contract, even if there is no formal change order. The contractor later seeks compensation for this additional work. Constructive change orders often result from unclear or ambiguous contract terms.
- Emergency Change Order
Issued when immediate changes are necessary to address unforeseen issues that could affect the safety or integrity of the project. These changes are often expedited and implemented without the usual review process due to the urgency.
Understanding these types of change orders helps in managing them effectively and ensuring that the project stays on track despite any necessary modifications.
Widen your understanding of the construction workflows with our comprehensive guide about the Different Types of Information in Construction Projects!
So, how exactly does this process work, from spotting the need for a change to implementing it? Here's a step-by-step walkthrough.
How Does the Change Order Process Work?
The change order process in construction is a systematic approach to managing modifications to a project’s original scope, cost, or schedule. Here’s how the process typically works:
1. Identification of the Need for a Change
- Initiation: The need for a change is identified by the client, contractor, architect, or another project stakeholder. This could be due to design changes, unforeseen site conditions, client requests, regulatory changes, or other factors.
- Assessment: The potential impact of the change on the project’s scope, budget, and timeline is assessed. This includes evaluating whether the change is necessary or if alternative solutions exist.
2. Documentation of the Change
- Proposal Creation: The contractor or architect creates a formal change order proposal. This document includes a detailed description of the proposed change, the reasons for it, the estimated cost impact, and the effect on the project schedule.
- Supporting Documents: Additional documentation, such as revised drawings, specifications, or cost estimates, may be included to provide clarity on the proposed changes.
3. Review and Approval
- Client Review: The client reviews the change order proposal, including the cost and schedule implications. They may request further clarification or modifications before agreeing to the change.
- Negotiation: If the client disagrees with any aspect of the proposal, negotiations may take place to reach a mutually acceptable solution. This could involve adjusting the scope, cost, or timeline.
4. Implementation of the Change
- Execution: The contractor proceeds with implementing the approved change. This may involve adjusting the work plan, procuring new materials, or coordinating with subcontractors.
- Communication: All relevant parties, including subcontractors and suppliers, are informed of the change and its impact on the project. Clear communication is essential to ensure everyone is aligned and can adjust their work accordingly.
5. Documentation and Record Keeping
- Record Maintenance: The approved change order, along with all supporting documentation, is added to the project’s official records. This ensures transparency and provides a reference for future project audits or disputes.
- Tracking: The change order is tracked to monitor its impact on the project’s budget and timeline. This tracking helps in managing multiple change orders and maintaining control over the project.
6. Adjustment of Project Controls
- Budget Adjustment: The project’s budget is adjusted to reflect the cost of the change order. This could involve reallocating funds or securing additional financing.
- Schedule Update: The project timeline is updated to incorporate the changes. This may involve extending deadlines, revising milestones, or adjusting resource allocation.
The change order process ensures that any modifications to the project are managed systematically, minimizing disruptions and maintaining project control. Proper handling of change orders is crucial to keeping the project on track and avoiding disputes.
Want to know what makes a change order crystal clear and foolproof? Let’s go over the essentials.
Essential Things Every Change Order Should Include
Every change order in construction should be comprehensive and clear to ensure that all parties understand the implications of the proposed change. Here are the essential elements that every change order should include:
1. Change Order Number
- Unique Identifier: A unique number or code to distinguish the change order from others in the project. This helps in tracking and referencing the change order throughout the project’s lifecycle.
2. Project Information
- Project Name and Location: The name and location of the project to ensure the change order is correctly associated with the right project.
- Contractor and Client Details: Names, addresses, and contact information of both the contractor and the client, as well as any other key stakeholders like architects or engineers.
3. Date of Issue
- Date of the Change Order: The date the change order is issued, which is critical for tracking the timeline and understanding when the change was requested and approved.
4. Description of the Change
- Detailed Description: A clear, detailed explanation of the change being proposed, including what is being added, removed, or modified. This should be specific and avoid ambiguity.
- Reason for the Change: An explanation of why the change is necessary, such as unforeseen conditions, client requests, or design errors.
5. Impact on Project Scope
- Scope Changes: A clear statement of how the change will affect the overall project scope. This includes whether the change adds new work, reduces work, or alters the existing scope.
6. Cost Impact
- Cost Estimate: A detailed breakdown of the estimated cost associated with the change. This should include materials, labor, equipment, and any other relevant expenses.
- Adjustment to Contract Price: The total increase or decrease in the contract price due to the change order. This should be clearly stated, along with the new contract value after the change.
7. Schedule Impact
- Time Extension or Reduction: An analysis of how the change will affect the project schedule, including any extension or reduction in the completion date. Specific milestones or deadlines that are impacted should also be noted.
- Revised Timeline: If applicable, a new project timeline should be provided, showing the updated schedule.
8. Contract Terms
- Reference to Original Contract: A reference to the specific sections or clauses of the original contract that are being modified by the change order.
- Compliance with Contractual Obligations: A statement ensuring that the change order complies with the contractual obligations and any necessary legal or regulatory requirements.
9. Signatures of Approval
- Client/Owner Signature: The signature of the client or project owner, indicating their approval of the change and acceptance of the revised cost, scope, and schedule.
- Contractor Signature: The signature of the contractor, indicates their agreement to execute the change as specified.
- Architect/Engineer Signature: If applicable, the architect or engineer’s signature, particularly if the change affects the design or structural integrity of the project.
10. Supporting Documentation
- Revised Drawings or Specifications: Any updated drawings, specifications, or plans that are required to implement the change should be attached or referenced.
- Cost Breakdown: A detailed breakdown of costs, including labor, materials, equipment, and overhead, should be included for transparency.
- Schedule Analysis: If the schedule is impacted, an analysis or revised Gantt chart showing the updated timeline should be provided.
11. Change Order Conditions
- Payment Terms: Any specific terms related to the payment for the change order work, including when and how the payment will be made.
- Warranty or Guarantee Adjustments: If the change affects the project’s warranty or guarantees, these adjustments should be clearly stated.
12. Dispute Resolution Clause
- Process for Disputes: A clause that outlines the process for resolving any disputes that may arise from the change order, ensuring that there is a clear path for addressing disagreements.
Including these elements in a change order ensures that all aspects of the proposed change are clearly defined, agreed upon, and documented, reducing the risk of disputes and misunderstandings as the project progresses.
Read about the Top AI Technologies for Construction Management in 2024 for enhanced construction management experience!
Curious about who does what in change order management? Here's a detailed rundown.
Chain of Responsibilities in Change Order Management
In change order management, multiple stakeholders have specific responsibilities to ensure that changes are handled efficiently and that the project remains on track. Here’s a breakdown of the key responsibilities:
1. Client/Project Owner
- Initiate Change Requests: The client may identify and request changes to the project’s scope, design, materials, or schedule based on evolving needs or preferences.
- Review and Approve Proposals: The client is responsible for reviewing change order proposals submitted by the contractor. They must approve or negotiate the terms, including any associated costs and timeline adjustments.
- Provide Necessary Information: The client should supply any additional details or clarification needed to facilitate the change order process.
- Authorize Funding: If the change order increases project costs, the client must approve the necessary budget adjustments.
2. Contractor
- Identify the Need for Changes: Contractors may recognize the need for changes due to site conditions, design errors, or other factors, and should promptly communicate these to the client.
- Prepare Change Order Proposals: Contractors are responsible for drafting detailed change order proposals, including scope adjustments, cost estimates, and schedule impacts.
- Negotiate Terms: Contractors may need to negotiate the terms of the change order with the client, ensuring that the changes are feasible and fair.
- Implement Approved Changes: Once a change order is approved, the contractor must execute the changes, coordinating with subcontractors and suppliers as necessary.
- Document and Track Changes: Contractors should maintain accurate records of all change orders and monitor their impact on the project’s budget and schedule.
3. Architect/Engineer
- Assess Design Impact: Architects and engineers evaluate how the proposed change will affect the project’s design, ensuring it meets safety, functionality, and aesthetic standards.
- Revise Drawings and Specifications: They are responsible for updating project drawings, specifications, and other technical documents to reflect the approved changes.
- Provide Technical Guidance: Architects and engineers may offer technical advice to ensure the change is practical and aligns with project goals.
- Approve or Reject Change Orders: In some cases, architects or engineers have the authority to approve or reject change orders, particularly those affecting design integrity.
4. Project Manager
- Facilitate Communication: Project managers ensure clear communication among all stakeholders throughout the change order process.
- Coordinate the Change Process: They oversee the entire change order process, from initiation to implementation, ensuring that the project remains on track.
- Monitor Schedule and Budget Impact: Project managers assess how the change order affects the project’s timeline and budget, making necessary adjustments to the project plan.
- Ensure Compliance: They are responsible for ensuring that the change order complies with the contract and any regulatory requirements.
- Track and Report Changes: Project managers maintain records of all change orders and regularly update stakeholders on their status and impact.
5. Subcontractors/Suppliers
- Assess Feasibility: Subcontractors and suppliers may need to evaluate the feasibility of proposed changes, particularly regarding material availability and labor requirements.
- Implement Changes: They are responsible for executing the approved changes in their specific areas of work under the direction of the general contractor.
- Communicate Challenges: If issues arise during the implementation of a change order, subcontractors and suppliers should promptly communicate them to the contractor and project manager.
6. Legal/Contractual Advisors
- Review Contractual Implications: Legal advisors may be involved in reviewing how the change order affects the original contract, ensuring that it is properly documented and compliant with legal standards.
- Assist in Dispute Resolution: They may help resolve disputes related to the change order process, guiding contractual obligations and rights.
Each role is crucial for managing change orders effectively, ensuring that changes are well-documented, agreed upon, and smoothly integrated into the project without unnecessary delays or cost overruns.
Next, let's tackle some of the common challenges that can knock your change order management off course.
Common Challenges in Change Order Management
Common challenges in change order management can disrupt project timelines, budgets, and overall success. Here are some of the key challenges:
- Poor Communication: Misunderstandings and delays in approvals can occur due to inadequate communication between stakeholders, leading to confusion about the scope, cost, and schedule impacts of change orders.
- Incomplete Documentation: Insufficient or inconsistent documentation can cause execution errors, make tracking changes difficult, and lead to disputes among project participants.
- Cost Overruns: Unanticipated expenses and difficulties in managing multiple change orders can result in budget overruns, straining the project’s financial resources.
- Schedule Delays: Change orders often extend project timelines, causing delays and potential penalties, while resource reallocation can disrupt the original schedule.
- Disputes and Conflicts: Disagreements over contract terms or differing opinions on the necessity or execution of a change order can lead to conflicts among stakeholders.
- Scope Creep: Uncontrolled changes can lead to scope creep, expanding the project beyond its original intent and impacting both time and budget.
- Regulatory Compliance: Ensuring that changes comply with local building codes and regulations can be challenging, particularly in complex projects.
- Impact on Project Quality: Rushed or poorly managed changes may compromise the quality of work, negatively affecting the overall project outcome.
Managing these challenges effectively requires clear communication, thorough documentation, accurate cost and schedule assessments, and a strong understanding of contractual obligations.
Do you wanna know about efficient construction management? Go through our detailed guide: Document Management In Construction: Benefits & Best Practices!
And if you’re looking to boost your change order management, Sonarlabs offers just what you require!
Optimize Change Order Management with Sonarlabs
Sonarlabs can enhance change order management through AI-powered document search and management solutions. Here’s how:
- Efficient Document Retrieval: Quickly locate and access change order documentation, including proposals, revisions, and approvals, reducing time spent searching for critical information.
- Streamlined Collaboration: Facilitate better communication among stakeholders by providing a centralized platform for sharing and discussing change order details, ensuring everyone is on the same page.
- Integration with Project Management Tools: Seamlessly integrate with existing project management systems to synchronize change order information and updates across all platforms.
- Enhanced Search Capabilities: Quickly find relevant documents, such as previous change orders or related project files, using advanced search features that save time and reduce manual effort.
Sonarlabs’ solutions help streamline the change order process, improve accuracy, and enhance overall project management efficiency. Sign up today to know more!
Conclusion
Therefore, effective change order management is essential for the success of any construction project. It helps maintain control over project scope, budget, and timelines, ensuring that adjustments do not derail progress or inflate costs. However, managing these changes can be complex and time-consuming, often leading to inefficiencies and potential conflicts.
This is where Sonarlabs comes in. By leveraging advanced AI technology, Sonarlabs offers a suite of tools designed to streamline and simplify the change order process. With its efficient document retrieval capabilities, you can quickly access and manage all relevant change order documentation, reducing the time spent searching for crucial information.
Book a demo and see how our solutions can enhance your change order management experience.
